FANDOM


Georgian Proposal for the Reconciliation of the Armenian and Orthodox ChurchesEdit

  1. On the issue of Apostolic Succession and its administration, the Armenian and Orthodox Churches agree that:
    1. The Orthodox Church recognizes the Armenian Church's descent from the Apostles Bartholomew and Thaddeus; the Armenian Church recognizes the Orthodox Church's descent from the Apostle Andrew.
    2. If the Armenian Church rejoins the Orthodox community, the Armenian Church will be combined into the Georgian Patriarchate of Kartli. The Armenian Church will remain autonomous in all aspects except the appointment of the Patriarch and those aspects discussed at this Council, or at future ecumenical councils. (Struck in compliance with Armenia's request. TankOfMidgets (talk) 01:09, February 25, 2014 (UTC))
    3. The symbolic Patriarch of Georgia and Armenia shall be appointed by a joint council of the bishops of the Georgian and Armenian churches, requiring a majority vote from both churches for his confirmation.
    4. The Georgian and Armenian Churches both acknowledge the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople as "first among equals" within the Orthodox community.
  2. On theological issues, the Armenian Church and Orthodox Church agree that:
    1. The Armenian Church's interpretation of the Trinitarian relationship as miaphysitic (one unified nature of both human and divine origins, in a single person) rather than dyophysitic (two natures, one human and one divine, in a single person) is technically incorrect. However, the perfect unity of Christ's two natures makes the two positions indistinguishable. Accordingly, the Orthodox Church accepts the miaphysitic position as an orthodox interpretation of the nature of Christ, barring further divine revelations on the subject.
    2. The Christological doctrines of Monothelitism and Monoenergism are heretical, and shall be tolerated in neither the Armenian nor the Orthodox Church.
    3. The use of icons of holy figures such as theTheotokos or the Savior encourage worshippers to emulate these sacred persons, and aid in the transmission of divine grace to fallen mankind. Accordingly, the Armenian Church recognizes the utility of these icons in the salvation of souls, and endorses their use in prayer.
  3. On liturgical issues, the Armenian and Orthodox churches agree that:
    1. The lack of icons in the Armenian Rite is a serious impediment to the extension of God's grace into the Armenian Church. Accordingly, the Armenian Church shall endeavor to acquire suitable sacred icons for its liturgies as soon as possible, purchasing these from the icon-makers of the Roman Empire where possible.
    2. The Armenian and Orthodox Churches shall convene a joint conference of bishops to examine the structure of the Armenian liturgy and determine whether it is the ideal form of the Eucharist. Until such a conference has been convened, the Armenian Church may continue to use its present form of the Eucharist.
    3. The marriage of Armenian priests is acceptable to the Orthodox Church, and shall continue unchanged. (Removed per Lx's suggestions, since it was common practice on both sides. Thanks, Lx - I thought it was tolerated, but not expected, which shows how little I know. TankOfMidgets (talk) 23:56, February 20, 2014 (UTC))

Counter-ProposalsEdit

(If either of the other two parties has a counter-offer, list the terms you've changed and post them here. I don't expect this to be a purely take-it-or-leave-it discussion, and am willing to talk it over.) TankOfMidgets (talk) 22:22, February 20, 2014 (UTC)

The thing about priest marriage is redundant as orthodox non-monastic priests are unofficialy expected to be married before ordination-Lx (leave me a message)25px 22:33, February 20, 2014 (UTC)

The only thing the Romans question is the merging of the Armenian and Georgian churches into one, and as such would like to hear the rational behind such a decision. "This is not your grave but you are welcome in it." 03:10, February 21, 2014 (UTC)

The Georgian Patriarch understands the hesitance of the Romans in approving such a shift in Church structure: the merging of two Patriarchates into one is not a decision to be undertaken lightly, as too much accumulation of power in a single body could enable another Bishop of Rome to overstep his authority and attempt to dictate policy for the entire Church. Indeed, the Georgian Church is willing to accept advisors from the Patriarch of Constantinople in order to ensure the purity of Christian doctrine in the newly-united Church. In this case, however, the Georgian Church respectfully notes that the proposed merger merely returns the Orthodox Church in the Caucasian region to its status quo prior to the departure of the Armenian Church from the greater Orthodox community in the mid-6th century.

Prior to the Armenian Church's departure from the greater Orthodox community, the Georgian and Armenian Churches typically convened joint congregations of both churches to discuss responses to doctrinal questions and to coordinate evangelization efforts in the then-pagan Caucasus. As the Kingdom of Armenia and the Kingdoms of Colchis and Iberia formed the boundary between the Christian Roman world and the pagan Scythians, this joint administrative arrangement enabled the two Churches to more effectively respond to challenges from other faiths such as the Zoroastrianism of the Persians. Though this alliance came unglued at the Third Council of Dvin, in which the Georgian and Armenian Churches fell out over the merits of the Chalcedonian position on the nature of Christ, it nonetheless solidified this portion of the Roman frontier until the rise of Islam in the 7th and 8th centuries.

The present situation in the Caucasus mirrors the ancient one: once more, the Christian world is beset by foes on all sides, and needs a unified religious response to resist the invaders. Given the historic ties between the Georgian and Armenian Churches, the Catholicos Shio II believes the combination of these two Churches into a single body offers the best chance of ensuring the continued growth of the true Christian church in the Caucasus. If successful, this initiative would also open the path to the reconciliation of the so-called Coptic Churches of Alexandria and the East with Constantinople - a prospect, we imagine, that should greatly please both the Patriarch and the Emperor of the Romans. TankOfMidgets (talk) 19:57, February 21, 2014 (UTC)

 SignatoriesEdit

-- -- This module will implement Template loop detected: Template:Navbox --

local p = {}

local HtmlBuilder = require('Module:HtmlBuilder') local navbar = require('Module:Navbar')._navbar local getArgs -- lazily initialized

local args local tableRowAdded = false local border local listnums = {}

local function trim(s)

   return (mw.ustring.gsub(s, "^%s*(.-)%s*$", "%1"))

end

local function addNewline(s)

   if s:match('^[*:;#]') or s:match('^{|') then
       return '\n' .. s ..'\n'
   else
       return s
   end

end

local function addTableRow(tbl)

   -- If any other rows have already been added, then we add a 2px gutter row.
   if tableRowAdded then
       tbl
           .tag('tr')
               .css('height', '2px')
               .tag('td')
               	.attr('colspan',2)
   end

   tableRowAdded = true

   return tbl.tag('tr')

end

local function renderNavBar(titleCell)

   -- Depending on the presence of the navbar and/or show/hide link, we may need to add a spacer div on the left
   -- or right to keep the title centered.
   local spacerSide = nil

   if args.navbar == 'off' then
       -- No navbar, and client wants no spacer, i.e. wants the title to be shifted to the left. If there's
       -- also no show/hide link, then we need a spacer on the right to achieve the left shift.
       if args.state == 'plain' then spacerSide = 'right' end
   elseif args.navbar == 'plain' or (not args.name and mw.getCurrentFrame():getParent():getTitle() == 'Template:Navbox' and (border == 'subgroup' or border == 'child' or border == 'none')) then
       -- No navbar. Need a spacer on the left to balance out the width of the show/hide link.
       if args.state ~= 'plain' then spacerSide = 'left' end
   else
       -- Will render navbar (or error message). If there's no show/hide link, need a spacer on the right
       -- to balance out the width of the navbar.
       if args.state == 'plain' then spacerSide = 'right' end

       titleCell.wikitext(navbar{ 
           args.name, 
           mini = 1, 
           fontstyle = (args.basestyle or ) .. ';' .. (args.titlestyle or ) ..  ';background:none transparent;border:none;'
       })
   end

   -- Render the spacer div.
   if spacerSide then
       titleCell
           .tag('span')
               .css('float', spacerSide)
               .css('width', '6em')
               .wikitext(' ')
   end

end

-- -- Title row -- local function renderTitleRow(tbl)

   if not args.title then return end

   local titleRow = addTableRow(tbl)

   if args.titlegroup then
       titleRow
           .tag('th')
               .attr('scope', 'row')
               .addClass('navbox-group')
               .addClass(args.titlegroupclass)
               .cssText(args.basestyle)
               .cssText(args.groupstyle)
               .cssText(args.titlegroupstyle)
               .wikitext(args.titlegroup)
   end

   local titleCell = titleRow.tag('th').attr('scope', 'col')

   if args.titlegroup then
       titleCell
           .css('border-left', '2px solid #fdfdfd')
           .css('width', '100%')
   end

   local titleColspan = 2
   if args.imageleft then titleColspan = titleColspan + 1 end
   if args.image then titleColspan = titleColspan + 1 end
   if args.titlegroup then titleColspan = titleColspan - 1 end

   titleCell
       .cssText(args.basestyle)
       .cssText(args.titlestyle)
       .addClass('navbox-title')
       .attr('colspan', titleColspan)

   renderNavBar(titleCell)

   titleCell
        .tag('div')
            .addClass(args.titleclass)
            .css('font-size', '110%')
            .wikitext(addNewline(args.title))

end

-- -- Above/Below rows --

local function getAboveBelowColspan()

   local ret = 2
   if args.imageleft then ret = ret + 1 end
   if args.image then ret = ret + 1 end
   return ret

end

local function renderAboveRow(tbl)

   if not args.above then return end

   addTableRow(tbl)
       .tag('td')
           .addClass('navbox-abovebelow')
           .addClass(args.aboveclass)
           .cssText(args.basestyle)
           .cssText(args.abovestyle)
           .attr('colspan', getAboveBelowColspan())
           .tag('div')
               .wikitext(addNewline(args.above))

end

local function renderBelowRow(tbl)

   if not args.below then return end

   addTableRow(tbl)
       .tag('td')
           .addClass('navbox-abovebelow')
           .addClass(args.belowclass)
           .cssText(args.basestyle)
           .cssText(args.belowstyle)
           .attr('colspan', getAboveBelowColspan())
           .tag('div')
               .wikitext(addNewline(args.below))

end

-- -- List rows -- local function renderListRow(tbl, listnum)

   local row = addTableRow(tbl)

   if listnum == 1 and args.imageleft then
       row
           .tag('td')
               .addClass('navbox-image')
               .addClass(args.imageclass)
               .css('width', '0%')
               .css('padding', '0px 2px 0px 0px')
               .cssText(args.imageleftstyle)
               .attr('rowspan', 2 * #listnums - 1)
               .tag('div')
                   .wikitext(addNewline(args.imageleft))
   end

   if args['group' .. listnum] then
       local groupCell = row.tag('th')

       groupCell
              .attr('scope', 'row')
              .addClass('navbox-group')
              .addClass(args.groupclass)
              .cssText(args.basestyle)

       if args.groupwidth then
           groupCell.css('width', args.groupwidth)
       end

       groupCell
           .cssText(args.groupstyle)
           .cssText(args['group' .. listnum .. 'style'])
           .wikitext(args['group' .. listnum])
   end

   local listCell = row.tag('td')

   if args['group' .. listnum] then
       listCell
           .css('text-align', 'left')
           .css('border-left-width', '2px')
           .css('border-left-style', 'solid')
   else
       listCell.attr('colspan', 2)
   end

   if not args.groupwidth then 
       listCell.css('width', '100%')
   end

   local isOdd = (listnum % 2) == 1
   local rowstyle = args.evenstyle
   if isOdd then rowstyle = args.oddstyle end

   local evenOdd
   if args.evenodd == 'swap' then
       if isOdd then evenOdd = 'even' else evenOdd = 'odd' end
   else
       if isOdd then evenOdd = args.evenodd or 'odd' else evenOdd = args.evenodd or 'even' end
   end

   listCell
       .css('padding', '0px')
       .cssText(args.liststyle)
       .cssText(rowstyle)
       .cssText(args['list' .. listnum .. 'style'])
       .addClass('navbox-list')
       .addClass('navbox-' .. evenOdd)
       .addClass(args.listclass)
       .tag('div')
           .css('padding', (listnum == 1 and args.list1padding) or args.listpadding or '0em 0.25em')
           .wikitext(addNewline(args['list' .. listnum]))

   if listnum == 1 and args.image then
       row
           .tag('td')
               .addClass('navbox-image')
               .addClass(args.imageclass)
               .css('width', '0%')
               .css('padding', '0px 0px 0px 2px')
               .cssText(args.imagestyle)
               .attr('rowspan', 2 * #listnums - 1)
               .tag('div')
                   .wikitext(addNewline(args.image))
   end

end


-- -- Tracking categories --

local function needsHorizontalLists()

   if border == 'child' or border == 'subgroup'  or args.tracking == 'no' then return false end

   local listClasses = {'plainlist', 'hlist', 'hlist hnum', 'hlist hwrap', 'hlist vcard', 'vcard hlist', 'hlist vevent'}
   for i, cls in ipairs(listClasses) do
       if args.listclass == cls or args.bodyclass == cls then
           return false
       end
   end

   return true

end

local function hasBackgroundColors()

   return mw.ustring.match(args.titlestyle or ,'background') or mw.ustring.match(args.groupstyle or ,'background') or mw.ustring.match(args.basestyle or ,'background')

end

local function getTrackingCategories()

   local cats = {}
   if needsHorizontalLists() then table.insert(cats, 'Navigational boxes without horizontal lists') end
   if hasBackgroundColors() then table.insert(cats, 'Navboxes using background colours') end
   return cats

end

local function renderTrackingCategories(builder)

   local title = mw.title.getCurrentTitle()
   if title.namespace ~= 10 then return end -- not in template space
   local subpage = title.subpageText
   if subpage == 'doc' or subpage == 'sandbox' or subpage == 'testcases' then return end

   for i, cat in ipairs(getTrackingCategories()) do
       builder.wikitext() 
   end

end

-- -- Main navbox tables -- local function renderMainTable()

   local tbl = HtmlBuilder.create('table')
       .attr('cellspacing', 0)
       .addClass('nowraplinks')
       .addClass(args.bodyclass)

   if args.title and (args.state ~= 'plain' and args.state ~= 'off') then
       tbl
           .addClass('collapsible')
           .addClass(args.state or 'autocollapse')
   end

   tbl.css('border-spacing', 0)
   if border == 'subgroup' or border == 'child' or border == 'none' then
       tbl
           .addClass('navbox-subgroup')
           .cssText(args.bodystyle)
           .cssText(args.style)
   else -- regular navobx - bodystyle and style will be applied to the wrapper table
       tbl
           .addClass('navbox-inner')
           .css('background', 'transparent')
           .css('color', 'inherit')
   end
   tbl.cssText(args.innerstyle)

   renderTitleRow(tbl)
   renderAboveRow(tbl)
   for i, listnum in ipairs(listnums) do
       renderListRow(tbl, listnum) 
   end
   renderBelowRow(tbl)

   return tbl

end

function p._navbox(navboxArgs)

   args = navboxArgs

   for k, v in pairs(args) do
       local listnum = ( .. k):match('^list(%d+)$')
       if listnum then table.insert(listnums, tonumber(listnum)) end
   end
   table.sort(listnums)

   border = trim(args.border or args[1] or )

   -- render the main body of the navbox
   local tbl = renderMainTable()

   -- render the appropriate wrapper around the navbox, depending on the border param
   local res = HtmlBuilder.create()
   if border == 'none' then
       res.node(tbl)
   elseif border == 'subgroup' or border == 'child' then
       -- We assume that this navbox is being rendered in a list cell of a parent navbox, and is
       -- therefore inside a div with padding:0em 0.25em. We start with a </div> to avoid the
-- padding being applied, and at the end add a
to balance out the parent's
       res
           .tag('/div', {unclosed = true})
               .done()
           .node(tbl)
           .tag('div', {unclosed = true})
   else
       res
           .tag('table')
               .attr('cellspacing', 0)
               .addClass('navbox')
               .css('border-spacing', 0)
               .cssText(args.bodystyle)
               .cssText(args.style)
               .tag('tr')
                   .tag('td')
                       .css('padding', '2px')
                       .node(tbl)
   end

   renderTrackingCategories(res)

   return tostring(res)

end

function p.navbox(frame)

   if not getArgs then
   	getArgs = require('Module:Arguments').getArgs
   end
   args = getArgs(frame)

   -- Read the arguments in the order they'll be output in, to make references number in the right order.
   local _
   _ = args.title
   _ = args.above
   for i = 1, 20 do
       _ = args["group" .. tostring(i)]
       _ = args["list" .. tostring(i)]
   end    
   _ = args.below

   return p._navbox(args)

end

return p

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.